Editorial Board

Annual Subscription

Past Issues

Suggested Topics

Manuscript Guidelines

Submission Process

Processing & Publishing Fee

Submission Deadlines

Reviewer Guidelines & Paper Evaluation Process

Swift Remittance

Managing Editor



Journals HOME

Name of Author of reviewed Work:

Name of Reviewer:

Title of Paper:



1) In your own words, please describe the research of the paper you are reviewing in 2-3 sentences


2) Please provide comments on what you think were GOOD in the paper.


3) Discuss the overall clarity of the paper. Is there anything specific you would like to address in any specific area? (Introduction, Methodology, Analysis of Data, Results, Conclusion, Discussion, etc.)


4) Read the abstract before and after reading the paper. Does the abstract adequately summarize the author's work?


5) Does the paper address the necessary categories required by the paper rubric? If no, please indicate the missing areas. Also comments on style, figure, grammar, references, etc. It may be easier to comment on this question on the copy of the paper itself.


6) Please provide recommendations for the author to improve her or his paper.


Paper Evaluation Process:

            Paper must not have been previously published or currently submitted for publication elsewhere. All papers should be submitted to the Managing Editor and will be evaluated for originality, significance, clarity and technical correctness. Names of referees will be kept confidential, but their comments will be made known to the corresponding author at the discretion of the Editor-in-Chief. Authors are solely responsible for the accuracy of statements made in the paper. Proof will be suitable edited by the Editor-in-Chief.



Download Reviewer Guidelines File in MSWord format



Contact Email: aesjournal@yahoo.com, aesjournal@rediffmail.com, grkulkarni29264@rediffmail.com